The Old Fireside in New York

"I was recommended this place by my dad and I’m very impressed, the food was absolutely delicious and I’ve never seen this place so clean from the last owners. Our server was super nice and i was impressed with the drink he made me, he said he’s only made it 3 times and it was so good. There were things on the menu that I haven’t seen anywhere else and a big plus is everything being fried in beef tallow. The beef was super tender and the pizza is probably the best I’ve had in the area. We played some pool and darts, had a great time."

"I attended a retirement party at The Old Fireside this afternoon. There was about 13 in our party. Nick was very accommodating and greeted us at the door. I'd first like to comment that the inside was beautifully upgraded since the last owners. The floors and bar looks amazing. I ordered fried pickles and mozzarella wedges for my appetizers which were 1/2 off till 2:00 on Mondays. The cheese pull on those wedges were top notch and the best tasting. That's the first time I've ever had fried pickles and they were delicious. For my meal I ordered the Hawaiian Habanero Salad. It was one of the best salads I've ever had!! I highly recommend it if you like your salad with a little heat. Our server was amazing also. She was kind, patient and thorough. (We all had separate checks) We were there almost three hours and wasn't rushed at all. Overall, we had a great time and ate great food."

"The pizza & wings were top tier! Staff was super nice and accommodating of all our requests. It was busy on a Thursday night and the whole vibe was great. You can tell the regulars love the place for a reason. Will definitely be going back."

"Everything was really good and there's lots to distract you while you wait for your food, definitely recommend and will be back for sure, my 20 something kids loved it too."

"Had to check this place out after seeing it on the news and hearing how Nick uses clean ingredients and healthy oils. I had one of the best burgers I have ever had and the french fries were the best! Service was great and the atmosphere was cozy and a fun family environment. Well worth the few extra minutes it takes to go there from Binghamton. I will definitely return! Thank you Nick"

"We went here for wing night and all of our food came out quickly. Our server was very nice and helpful in assisting us with our order. We will definitely be back next Sunday!"

"I went to The Old Fireside last night and very happy with the service and food. They did a great job at remolding the location. Food was great! Didn't have to wait long even though they were very busy. I will be back to enjoy our local restaurant and Bar. Cost was reasonable as well, Thank you for a great experience."

"First time back since new ownership and everything was very impressive. I will say the staff was beyond friendly and it seems like they take pride in what they do. I was also impressed on the ingredients and how they fry with tallow which is a healthy fat to use. The pizza and the wings stood out as being the best food selections and were very fresh and tasty. The atmosphere is cozy and welcoming. Will definitely be back."